Kids cross Massachusetts Avenue in North Cambridge on bikes. (Photo: Marc Levy)

A proposal to fill gaps in Cambridge’s network of bike lanes was set aside Monday after no city Department of Transportation staff appeared to take questions from skeptical city councillor Cathie Zusy.

Because the city has made commitments to focus on dangerous intersections and parking issues, and with six miles of bike lanes to roll out by 2028, Zusy said it was the wrong time to approve a policy order proposing at least another 15 miles of coordinated network, even if some of the miles included just traffic calming and pedestrianizing rather than the planning and installation of separated bike lanes.

Advertisement

“We have really focused wholeheartedly on the bike lanes for the last five years, and we were promised that this transportation department was going to be thinking about things more broadly,” Zusy said. “Don’t we need a feasibility study for this? What is it going to cost? Completing the network is a great idea if it doesn’t get in the way of these other things.”

The city’s Cycling Safety Ordinance was introduced in 2019 to add bike lanes during street improvement projects and changed in 2020 to more aggressively require the installation of approximately 25 miles of separated lanes within seven years. Everywhere the lanes have been installed or announced, clashes have arisen over the parking spaces taken away to accommodate them, while advocates point to bicyclists injured and killed by cars as they try to share city streets, and say there will be less traffic when more people get out of their cars.

The new order led by councillor Patty Nolan would build on a 2024 order to fill gaps and improve connections between Cambridge, Somerville and Boston, focusing on schools as part of the bike lane network (such as linking the high school and playing fields at Danehy Park, as well as Union Square in Somerville to the BU Bridge and Kendall Square to the North Point neighborhood), and broaden the approach to include traffic calming. Nolan and her co-sponsors seek the introduction of at least three network miles each year from 2027 through 2031, for at least 15 miles, and an Ordinance Committee hearing as soon as possible.

City staff proposed in April 2025 a Cambridge Access and Mobility Plan that will coordinate all transportation and safety planning. “Before that process is done, we really need to continue the work on the network” for more north-south connections raised in the 2024 policy order, Nolan said. “We’ve heard over the many years that families and less confident riders are not comfortable taking more trips by bike until there’s a more complete network of lanes that allow them to get where they need to go safely. The limitations currently keep more people in cars.”

It wasn’t just Zusy who wanted to pump the brakes on the proposal. Councillor E. Denise Simmons, while saying she shared the goals of connected bike lanes, shared Zusy’s concern that a new goal was being moved ahead of decades of work on a Grand Junction multiuse path that could become part of the desired connections if city staff would just explain the status of the work. “An order about north-south connection that names a route starting at the BU Bridge but never mentions Grand Junction raises fair questions,” Simmons said.

Moving the conversation to the Transportation and Public Utilities Committee from the Ordinance Committee was proposed by councillor Tim Flaherty, the transportation committee’s chair. The idea was welcomed by Zusy and Simmons as allowing a deep discussion that was not time sensitive. 

Other councillors found the reasons beside the point. “This isn’t zoning, so there’s no timeline,” and a full conversation with the same staff can be held in Ordinance, which has the benefit of including all councillors as members, Jivan Sobrinho-Wheeler said. “If the transportation committee wants to have a separate conversation on it,” there’s nothing stopping Flaherty from calling one.

Nolan agreed that the Grand Junction needed to be expedited and included in the planning, and wanted to amend the policy order to include it. But the path should be part of maintaining momentum on the network, she said.

“The city has done unbelievably great work on this,” Nolan said. “The projects in the original CSO are all nearing completion, and that’s why it’s really important for us to have a plan for the next five years.”

The conversation can be picked up at the next council meeting, as Zusy on Monday used her “charter right” powers to stop the conversation only temporarily. Though Zusy said she wrote transportation commissioner Brooke McKenna last week with questions and expected responses Monday, McKenna was not present for the discussion.

“The answers to the questions about workload impacts depends on a lot of the specifics of what’s actually in the ordinance. It’s a little bit of a give-and-take conversation,” deputy city manager Kathy Watkins said in McKenna’s place.