From Federico Muchnik
Just because Just A Start can go as high as 12 stories (or more) doesn’t mean it has to (“Park moves to Massachusetts Avenue at a proposed pair of affordable apartment buildings residents are liking more,” Nov. 19). The skyscraper – for Cambridge, it’s a skyscraper – planned for 1840 Massachusetts Ave. is an aberration, must be stopped and reduced to somewhere around seven or eight stories. Why?
Public housing no longer has to be done this way. Developers building towers are repeating mistakes of the past. Going tall destroys communities, inside the tower and out. Don’t believe me? Ask the folks living at 21 Walden Square Road (nine stories, 200 units, I believe) if they’re fine staying where they are or would prefer living in affordable housing such as Roosevelt Towers, Lincoln Way or any of the other low- to midrise projects. To a person, they will answer they’d like housing on a more human and humane scale. Now ask the folks at the low-rise Lincoln Way townhouses if they’re happy and to a person they will say they are.
The 1840 Massachusetts Ave. project offers no “defensible space” (where parents can keep an eye on their kids playing), no true green space (the kids will not play in a pocket park), around 15 parking spaces (for 100 or so units, counting developer Just A Start’s second building across Mount Vernon Street).
Developers will talk about “economies of scale” and how building fewer units, going midrise, is simply not profitable enough. I call BS. Going tall is going lazy on several fronts. It turns a building into a cookie-cutter structure. After seven stories the repetition becomes obvious and inevitable. Going tall lumps dozens of units under one business proposition that ends up costing tens of millions of dollars more – anything above seven stories gets very expensive – than if developers build two buildings at six or seven stories each. Why don’t developers see that going midrise leads to faster financing and greater success rates? Banks would back projects with smaller budgets.
“But there’s simply not enough land,” the developers (and the city) will say, “for the midrise buildings. How can we begin to meet demand?” Answer: Developers need to get creative with less land. In the case of 1840, why not go two stories higher on the second building and come two or more stories down for the skyscraper? And, folks, no matter how much gets built, there will never be enough real estate relative to demand in what is already one of the densest and most desirable cities in the country.
Ideally, the city would incentivize developers into building midrise along the avenue. Count the floors on the tallest buildings between Harvard Square and Alewife: seven stories. Why seven? Because not only does a midrise building preserve a sense of scale and community, but it also sits proportionally well relative to the width of the avenue, never casting shadows cast by a tower of 12 (or more) stories.
Wind tunnels. Shadows. Loss of community, character, disproportionate size relative to the surroundings. The 1840 project would be two and half times taller Lesley’s University Hall across the street. Two and half times taller than the Henderson Carriage Building.
Folks, neighbors of Porter Square have spent decades building community, and we welcome the stranger. I’ve made films at Rindge Towers, documented the working class kids playing soccer at Danehy Park, filmed the mom-and-pop shops up and down Massachusetts Avenue run by shopkeepers that’ve been here for decades. Of course we want new, young, fresh faces here, but we want them to live good lives in spaces they want to stay in long term, places they can come to call home.
There’s an intelligent way to increase public housing in Cambridge. It’s not the old way of going tall. It’s the city, the citizens and the developers working together to fast-track gentle-density midrise housing along the city’s main artery. Take a walk from Harvard Square to Central Square. Note the canyon you’re walking through. Note the number of office towers. Note the paucity of “neighborhood,” the lack of character.
Just A Start (and Capstone, with its 12-story project at Massachusetts Avenue and Walden Street), working with our misguided city councillors, are making a statement: We’re coming to your neighborhood with tall buildings – and there’s nothing you can do about it. Or is there?
Federico Muchnik is a filmmaker living on Richdale Avenue in Cambridge.
