
A fourth-grader had to testify to Somerville’s School Committee to get long-broken restroom plumbing fixed at his school – a process that took weeks – but elected officials and staff find there’s a bigger problem to be addressed.
“How would you feel if you had nowhere to go to the bathroom in private? Winter Hill students deserve better bathrooms,” said the child, Thomas, reading from an essay at the Sept. 28 meeting of the School Committee. Despite there being only one boys’ bathroom for two floors and multiple grades at the school, only one stall was in order – and Thomas said such a situation had persisted since he was in second grade.
“One stall is fine. Two are missing doors, and two can’t lock. We have nowhere to poop in private,” Thomas said. “There are four urinals. One at the end of the row is missing a privacy wall. One jets water, and we call it The Blaster. Nobody wants to be sprayed with toilet water.”
The matter made its way to the City Council in October, where councilor Kristen Strezo introduced a resolution for repairs that noted the problem was even more widespread than Thomas reported. According to parents, a girls’ bathroom on the first floor of the Winter Hill School also has doors that don’t lock. “I’m not entirely sure why it’s gone on as long as it has and why it continues to be a problem,” Strezo said.
The Blaster is back to being an ordinary urinal as of Tuesday’s meeting of the city’s School Building Facilities and Maintenance Committee, which included councilors and School Committee members. Unfortunately, there’s a deeper problem of repeated vandalism that is straining resources, staff told the officials.
The Winter Hill Community Innovation School closed at 115 Sycamore St. in 2023 for safety concerns after a piece of concrete fell in a stairwell. When a structural review decided the building would never reopen, students and faculty were relocated, divided between the Edgerly Education Center and Capuano Early Childhood Center until a new, six-story school is built on Sycamore Street for 925 students – taking in not just Winter Hill kids, but those of the 126-year-old Benjamin G. Brown School not far from Ball Square. The school has a projected opening date of 2031.
Pressed into service
It’s the Edgerly building, pressed into use as a school in the meantime, that has hosted “The Blaster” and the other restroom maintenance issues.
“It’s an older building. Everyone says it’s got great bones, but it continues to be a challenge – and our students are going to be there for at least another five years,” said Laura Pitone, a School Committee member. “You can have a new baby and have it be in kindergarten by the time they’re done with this building.”
There’s been a lot of investment in the Edgerly to handle a “not ideal” situation as emergency swing space, Pitone said, but the elected officials wanted to know what issues remained and how they could be addressed more methodically and comprehensively. A request for a city website that would serve as a maintenance project tracker has languished since last year, councilor Naima Sait said.
“Every year we’re this close to having it make it to the top of the list,” Sait said.
While the city’s Public Works and Infrastructure Capital Projects Division are at work in almost all of the schools continually, a lack of five critical infrastructure staff members has the department “just scrambling,” said Rich Raiche, director of infrastructure and asset management for the city. “It’s very difficult for us to dedicate the time to stand up this webpage … between capital and engineering, there’s just too many projects.”
Repeated vandalism
That’s a little how Public Works director Eric Weisman feels about the Edgerly. Staff say the problematic restroom has been “repaired repeatedly and that it was damaged repeatedly,” Weisman said. “We’ve replaced 10 door partitions at that school since the the renovation happened. Most recently we replaced the doors, because we had run out of the the stock of doors that we had, with plywood – and within one day those doors were kicked in and the locks were damaged. It’s been a challenge keeping these bathrooms in operation.”
The issues of repeated vandalism are being on worked on with school administration, the central office and superintendent’s office, said Danielle Barry, facilities safety and transportation coordinator for Somerville Public Schools.
“Sometimes how people behave in an environment that maybe is not as new or ideal is unfortunate,” Pitone said.
It was also “really sad that it required a student to have to be that vulnerable to come up and explain the story,” School Committee member Elizabeth Eldridge said, referring to Thomas at the September meeting. “Being sprayed with toilet water is pretty gross.”
“Not funny”
Committee chair Jon Link and Weisman introduced the topic of The Blaster with a mild bit of humor: Weisman said he’d struggled to find the history of the repair in the 311 help-line logs, and Link asked mildly, “The urinal isn’t just labeled ‘The Blaster’?” After Weisman replied – “I don’t know who gave it that nickname and where that’s memorialized, but I can picture it” – the humor evaporated.
“These are real kids who need to use the bathroom, and when they go to use the bathroom and the urinal they’re going to use is going to spray them or their friends, that’s not funny. Respectfully to my counterparts here on the call,” School Committee member Leiran said. “I want to make sure we’re not trivializing the very real humiliation that a student might feel entering a bathroom and getting soaked by their urinal.”
Weisman expressed regret, saying he was making light of the name, not “any discomfort or embarrassment that any student would have.”
