The Cambridge Kiosk in Harvard Square on Nov. 2. (Photo: Marc Levy)

The Cambridge City Council seeks a new operator for Harvard Square’s kiosk. In case you hadn’t noticed, the small freestanding space by the T stop (and eternal construction site) has been run by the nonprofit CultureHouse since May 2025. Councillors fondly remember the kiosk’s role as a newsstand, as a gathering place and center of public life. Now the kiosk is moving to a “seasonal residency model” with four artists in charge of the space over the next year. Councillors agree the kiosk has turned into something closer to a museum than a place where people gather.

A CultureHouse representative responds to criticism: “The challenge isn’t a lack of creative possibilities, or the terms of our contract; it’s the resources available to realize those possibilities.”

Advertisement

No reflection – just give us more money, please.

Cambridge tries to be a city that values art in a generic sense. We think art is important, so we pay people to make and put it in public places. This is a feel-good proposition, but community doesn’t automatically equal art. Are the guys playing chess in the plaza in front of Smith making art? Was the guy selling newspapers out of the kiosk making art? To get art to replace these things is asking too much of it – if art provokes emotion and conservation, it’s already “good” in my book – we don’t need to ask artists to make up for where the rest of the city’s planning apparatus and nonprofit industrial complex fall short.

My annoying opinion of the week is that art is removed from day-to-day society. Since most of the “obvious” art has been made already, people make things that are new and interesting, but they don’t attract the average person. I know this because I write books that are largely uninteresting. There is kind of a misconception that art in itself is culture – that if you put art somewhere, it becomes cultural in some way. Culture is something that encompasses the habits and interests of broad groups of people, and while it can be invested in, it cannot be created by fiat or purchase.

If rent is too high for people to hang out in Harvard Square and blast punk music, and the city is too dysfunctional to fix the plaza so people can hang out in it, to whom does it write a check to make up the difference? CultureHouse. It has culture in the name! If you are a conservative (who dislikes big government) or a socialist (who dislikes privatization), you should be critical of this idea. I don’t think hiring an operator is a bad idea, but so far we’ve managed only to spend a lot of money for little cultural output.

As part of my research for this piece, I walked by CultureHouse’s office and saw that someone had a big ChatGPT window open on their computer. Well, maybe it’ll help. If you go to the website, this is the tagline: “CultureHouse started with a question … ‘What would a pop-up indoor public space look like?’” A pop-up indoor space? That’s it? There is something bleak in how unambitious this idea is. A solution to the decline of public life and socialization in America is … a pop-up indoor space? These are the ideas we’re paying for? It’s so bleak that I can’t write about it coherently without sounding curmudgeonly.

I’m into a high word count, so let’s dispense with some tired talking points: 1. The kiosk is undervisited because of the construction. No, if anything, since the rest of the square is fenced off, the kiosk should see even more foot traffic. 2. The kiosk has become an “essential cultural anchor.” Please let me know where you buy your weed. 3. People “wanted” the Office of Tourism to take up half the space. Don’t take advice about arts and culture from people who show up to public meetings. 

Thanks, that’s all the time I have. Oh, wait: Don’t forget to thaw your turkey completely in the refrigerator before cooking, or to call your mom, or to subscribe to the CS Indie newsletter.