
The Tune-Yard’s Merrill Garbus talks with the Indie about going “planetary” ahead of their show at the Paradise on Nov. 18. Their latest single is “The Ones.” The Oakland-based artist has traveled the world, one stage at a time, with her band mate and partner Nate Brenner, and that journey started in New England.
Garbus reflects on growing up in a musical household in Connecticut, grinding out Bono vocals with acapella groups in western Massachusetts, playing early gigs at open mics in Northampton and local venues like the Middle East and Club Passim, practicing puppetry in Vermont and recording a debut album with a dictaphone.
With a child, new creative projects like film scores, and years of experience in the public eye, Garbus thinks about the challenges that Tune-Yards tackles differently than when she started. But her message to herself, and to the community and culture she builds around her art, remains the same. It’s the same message she wrote on the inside of the tape release of her debut album, “Bird-Brains,” back in 2009.
It read: “You can do it.”
[The interview has been edited and condensed for publication.]
What is your approach to live shows these days? What can we expect walking into the club?
I have been really into trying to immediately involve the audience so we’re all singing together pretty quickly. There’s going to be more of that, and we’re going to do fan meetups this time.
It feels like, in this age of isolation, it’s not just about coming to the shows. It’s also about making the most of coming to the shows and really feeling like it’s an opportunity where people get to know each other and where people meet each other. And I know I’m biased, but Tune-Yards fans are historically some of the most open-hearted, great people to be around.
So we’ll do some of that and then we’ll try to blow minds. Nate and I have been playing together for a really long time now, and the glory of that is it’s just the two of us. I’m on loops, vocal loops, drum loops, ukulele singing; and he’s on bass and synth and pedals. Between the two of us, we just try to make a world of sound.
Somebody used these words, “getting immersed in sound.” And that’s what I want from our shows. We get to go to another place, almost physically, with sound. Something that’s been really important to me over the years is the transitions between songs. We do less of a singer-songwriter [presentation] like, “This is what this song is about,” and more taking people on a real ride, a sonic ride.
So no banter, or less banter.
Very little banter. I’ve really cut down. I’m a talker, so it took me years to realize that the banter was getting in the way of the musical experience.
You gotta watch out for that. I go to and work at a lot of shows, and banter, it can be 50 percent of the set.
Some people are there for that. But I want to go interplanetary with music, so you gotta take it out of the cerebral.
When is a good time to go on tour?
Fifteen years ago I would have said they have us touring a lot around a record release. You get the press and more people come to the shows. Now you throw your new music at a wall and you hope some algorithm puts it in somebody’s feed. So the best time to tour, I think, is all the time. Because people need live music. If I didn’t think people needed real live performance experiences, we wouldn’t do it.
I’m sure I’m not the first to say everything is so expensive: hotels are expensive, vans are expensive, gas is expensive. It doesn’t economically right now make a lot of sense to tour. But it’s our job and it’s what we do, and we love it. If live music wasn’t my passion, I would rethink where it fits into the whole economy.
Do you find yourself being more selective about how often you perform? If so, is that a Covid thing? Is that a new child thing? Is it a third thing or all the above?
It’s all the above, and the third thing is probably a thing we’ll have clarity about in 25 years, you know what I mean? These intersecting forces are contributing to the post-Covid tendency of people to stay at home, whether that’s actual Covid and people really needing to stay home or whether that’s a kind of a new kind of socializing or antisocializing.
We’ve taken our kid on every tour that we’ve been on since he was born. I actually don’t think that slowed us down – maybe it fired us up because we were like, “Oh shit, we have another mouth to feed.”
Venues say numbers haven’t returned to pre-Covid levels.
Venues are probably also saying people are drinking less. And the economy in general, right? People don’t have the spending cash they might have before.
You did the film score for this year’s Boots Riley-directed “I Love Boosters,” your second collaboration with Riley after “Sorry To Bother You” in 2019. What was that experience like?
Yeah, and we did a whole TV series with him too in between. “I’m a Virgo” (2023). It’s hard to tell what’s a “midcareer,” but we’re now midcareer artists versus that initial excitement when people had never heard us. [Branching out] is a good idea; that’s probably true for all bands that last as long as we have. Unless you’re the Rolling Stones, touring probably slows down a little bit.
Scoring was also just good musically. It got me out of feeling like all of my music needed to be for this one band that I started in my 20s. Instead we’ve now worked with string quartets doing arrangements for horns and different instrumentation and different textures than we would have ever done for Tune-Yards.
What’s the process for scoring? And to collaborate as a self-taught musician with people who might have had formal music training?
So far we’ve been really lucky to work with, for instance, Magik*Magik Orchestra, an ensemble based in San Francisco – people who are willing to go, “I know this is not your forte, to make these kinds of classical scores, but we can do this kind of massaging of the worlds of rock ’n’ roll with the classical. But I do have that theory background. My mom taught piano. I took lessons with her till I was 13. I dropped out of music class in college because it felt like math to me, and I was not interested in that. I trust my ear now, and Nate has his jazz background and his theory background.
Your parents met playing square dances in New York City. Your dad got you into jazz, your mom got you into classical. What was it like learning about and studying music with your parents?
I remember as a kid going, “I don’t know what I want to do when I grow up, but I know that I don’t want to be a musician,” because my parents are musicians. But of course then I studied theater, which was not so far removed.
A folk approach to music is something I really got from them, which I’m really grateful for, and that everybody can play music. The assumption is that we are humans and therefore we participate in music in some way. That’s really helped me in a lot of ways – not subscribing to this rock star mentality.
There was music around all the time. There was also study and an emphasis on really trying to devote oneself to practice, but I really wasn’t good at it. I was not disciplined and I was really hard on myself. It’s only in the last 10 years or so that I really have devoted myself more to understanding that practice gets me to the place where I need to be to take the things that I’m hearing in my brain and be able to put them in front of an audience.
I started taking classical voice lessons 14 or 15 years ago now. That really got me to [this point], aside from Mr. Sjögren – Arthur Sjögren – an amazing choral teacher at New Canaan High School, who gave me a really good foundation.
You were obsessed with a capella groups at college. Maybe that was a carryover from Mr. Sjögren?
Totally. I did madrigals and learned very classical technique in high school and then went to Smith College, performing in two groups there, the Smiffenpoofs and the Noteables, and I probably tried to sing like Stevie Wonder and Bono. Not the best technique for me.
I went to Smith because my aunt and uncle lived nearby in Florence, and my aunt said you should really go there. And she was right. After school I lived with them for a little bit. I was living in their basement and making music on eight-track recorders and then coming with my ukulele to open mics.
You recorded your debut album “Bird-Brains” (2009) into a dictaphone – something like a mid-20th century ad executive would speak notes into.
Yeah, pre-cellphone. It’s hard to remember that we needed something like that.
Do you still have that same dictaphone?
I do. Friends of mine in Vermont actually bought it for me. And I don’t know why, other than they knew I was writing songs that needed something. My dad used to call me a Luddite, so they decided that this was the most I’d want, a digital voice recorder. It also did not transfer files, as far as I could tell. I would take a cord and put it into the input of my computer and record in real time from the computer as I played back on the dictaphone. By the end, I was like. “Why did I do it this way?” By the end of the process, I had learned multitrack recording. And now I have Pro Tools, I’m super fast.
You moved to Oakland shortly before you recorded your second album “Whokill” (2011). Were you like, “Hell no, no more dictaphone” or “Well, maybe”? Or was the label like, “Hell no, we’re going to get you a real studio”?
I wanted to make sure that I kept my creative world. It felt under attack a little bit, and I was pretty stubborn about keeping my way of working and not being influenced in that way. On the first song, “My Country,” I am still singing through the dictaphone because I couldn’t get past that sound of the dictaphone that was compressing my voice in a specific way. And distorting it in a specific way. I felt like my voice sounded the way I wanted it to. Now I understand that was more my “producer’s head” coming in – this is how I want my voice to sound, and this is the way I know how to get it.
But Nate had been recording with Eli Cruz, who had the studio New, Improved Recording. I just had heard their recordings and it felt like they were gritty and nasty and real-sounding in a way that I trusted. And then instead of a click track, we used my looping pedal to set up a tempo, then Eli would map the tempo from my click track after the fact. So that if we needed to be on a grid, it was a human grid, if that makes sense, a human feel.
So we still use these things, a lot of which we still use to this day, that are Tune-Yards – Tune-Yardsian – ways of making music still feel human and not so robotic.
Did you make it out to perform in Boston during the early days of Tune-Yards?
I have to say how much Boston means to me. Boston, as you know, coming from the Pioneer Valley, was like the huge urban hub. Especially when we were in those early touring days, that was really important to get to Boston and figure out shows.
Where would you play in Boston?
We’ve played Paradise several times. [Best guess: Tune-Yards has played Paradise Rock Club three times, including opening for Dirty Projectors in 2009.] We opened for Thao & the Get Down Stay Down with my old band. I was trying to remember that the other day: What was the bill that we first shared? Both of us were just talking about how we’re still doing it.
T.T. the Bear’s Place? Does that ring a bell?
It does, but like, did we play there, or was it just we always tried to get a gig at T.T. the Bear’s and couldn’t? The Middle East I know we played at least twice, if not three times. I also was on tour a lot with Chris Pureka, an amazing singer-songwriter who used to be based out of the Pioneer Valley. That’s how I got started touring. What’s the singer-songwriter venue in Boston?
Well, there’s Passim in Cambridge.
Club Passim, yeah. Not with Tune-Yards, but maybe with Chris Pureka.

You recently did a collaboration with Thao?
Yeah, she just put out a record (“Show Me”) on Friday. Nate did a lot of production and co-writing on it, and I did some production as well. Yeah, so that’s cool. My friend that I met in Boston, and here we are, still friends and still collaborating after all these years. That’s really cool.
“Whokill” won the No. 1 spot on The Village Voice’s annual Pazz & Jop critics’ poll. A Tune-Yards’ breakthrough came pretty quick. Was it quick from your perspective?
“Whokill” contained songs that we had been working on on the road, so the album was probably 75 percent written, with songs we had tried out opening for Dirty Projectors, Xiu Xiu and others. We knew that “Gangsta” really hit and we knew that “Powa” really hit and “Bizness” really hit. We just needed to capture the energy of those songs onto that record. What it took was doing this record at a proper studio with a proper engineer.
I’m sure you remember in your 20s how everything felt long, right? I felt very old at 29. I had had a whole career as a puppeteer right after I graduated from college. And I felt like, “Oh, I’m getting in late … All these people are in bands from high school on, and I’m getting in late at 26. I’m so old.” Those years until my 30th birthday, I told myself that if I didn’t get signed to a label or I didn’t see music actually making me a living, that I would quit and figure out what else to do. I was living out of my car sometimes. I was on food stamps sometimes. I wasn’t the kind of adult making an income that I had heard you were supposed to be. And then on my 30th birthday, a person from a record label came in. The universe was like, “You’re 30 and you will have a record deal.”
I mean, again, I thought I was old at 30, and in that 30-to-34 range we toured nonstop. So to me, it was fast, but I was also grateful that I wasn’t 21 when that happened.
Also, we had toured so much with my band Sister Suvi that I also had gotten that sense of real DIY, like how to make a spreadsheet to figure out how much you could spend on food depending on how many burned CD-Rs you had sold the night before. How you could get this friend to do the poster art and then xerox it and plaster it up ourselves. Everything was just doing it ourselves and trying to bring people out to shows. I was grateful that I had that background.
When you have a record label infusing money into you, they want their return on investment pretty quickly. They put a lot into the project. I actually still wish that I had had a more hands-on approach back then.
What was out of your hands that you wish had been in your hands at the start?
Choices about certain music videos or what the stage setup should be. I always had friends helping me with costumes and style and makeup and things like that. But there was a lot of input, like people saying, “You can’t wear that on stage,” or “No, no, no, you don’t want that kind of video, you want this kind of video.” Most of the time it was from label people. But again, they were all trying to do their best to get the music out – and they did. Without 4AD, there would not have been that massive lift in exposure for us, right?
I owe them so much in so many ways in terms of bringing Tune-Yards to this wider audience. It’s just that I see it happen a lot. I also see artists who hold on tight to their creative vision, and I think that’s really important and good. I always encourage younger artists to just get your vision together. Increase the vision of the kind of culture you’re trying to create around your band, because now that we’re “midcareer” we’re really leaning on people who want to be part of the culture that our band represents versus it just being strictly about songs, strictly about what’s the most popular music right now.
What is the culture Tune-Yards is trying to cultivate and be part of?
A lot of it is encapsulated in the first cassette tape that I did of “Bird-Brains.” which said on Side A, “You can do it.” I felt like that was a huge part of it: involving listeners in the creative culture of the band. I’ve always wanted to involve people, whether that’s singing at shows or encouraging people to move their bodies at shows, encouraging people to interact with us at the merch table or whatever. It’s not this, “We’re up here and you’re down here” kind of rock ’n’ roll dynamic.
Much more the DIY ethos.
Yeah, which you can call a socialist ethos now, you know? A sense of collective power.
