Content warnings: homophobia, allusions to violence
Deep in a far-flung forest in Victorian England lies the isolated village of Farleigh. Folks fill their days tending orchards, life moves slow and things are peaceful. That is, until the Duke of Farleigh is murdered. And it’s no ordinary murder – the Duke is a beloved tree felled with the village’s only ax. Enter Havelock Harper, a celebrity detective whose exploits are chronicled in The Times newspaper by his companion, major Sebastian Wright. Havelock and Sebastian venture to Farleigh to investigate the Duke’s death, bringing readers along for a whimsical, woodsy mystery that is a welcome break from the modern world and a promising start to a series.
Author Oliver K. Langmead deftly invites readers into the vibrant world of Farleigh, depicting the village and surrounding forest with such precision that we can’t help imagine crunching through leaves and stepping over roots as we follow Havelock’s investigation. The fantastical feels real in Farleigh, and the tale’s fanciful pieces – such as the trees learning language from a long-buried library – feel comfortably matched by the gentle but insistent sense of wonder infusing the telling.
The core mystery – who killed the Duke and why – isn’t exactly a puzzle box. The investigation unfurls quickly, with Havelock and Sebastian putting pieces together as they interview a few key suspects: the gardener who thinks Farleigh should open up to the world, the teacher who would see the village completely cut off, the preacher caught in the middle and, of course, the Duchess of Farleigh (who is not a tree, but rather the aging heiress of Farleigh House). Endearing as we find Havelock, he stretches a touch too far filling in the details of the murderer’s motivation. Predictably, he’s spot on, and things wrap up rather neatly.
But though we may come to “The Killing of a Chestnut Tree” for a cozy magical mystery, we stay for the surprising depth and complex layers.
There’s commentary on British imperialism and connections to modern sensitivities about the pace of life in a hyperconnected world. There’s a strong vein of naturalism, with critique of resource exploitation and environmental destruction. There are meta-layers about the blurred lines between fact and fiction and the power of storytelling, bringing us to Havelock and Sebastian’s relationship and the brilliant frame story.
“The Killing of a Chestnut Tree” doesn’t open with the killing of the Duke, or anything to do with Farleigh. Instead, we start with two young men working the lonely night shift at a mill, where they find mysterious flowers left in significant spots. They reach out to Havelock and Sebastian, who share the unpublished manuscript detailing their investigation in Farleigh. As the mill workers read, they realize this story is connected to the mystery of the flowers in a surprising way.
In Sebastian’s reports for The Times, his relationship with Havelock always appears to be close, friendly and professional; in the manuscript about their time in Farleigh, Havelock and Sebastian are clearly more intimate – there’s no doubt that they are in love, a steady sort stemming from decades of life together. This shows the mill workers that another world, one in which we’re all free to love who we choose, is possible, and helps them unravel the mystery of the flowers.
This structure is sharpened by the second-person direct address – you, reader, are one of the mill workers reading about Farleigh and connecting the story back to your own mystery. We can imagine many interpolations of this technique, and trust that future entries in the budding Havelock Harper series will offer new and intriguing ways of bringing us into a fantastical world.
Hardcore mystery fans may find “The Killing of a Chestnut Tree” too easy, but devoted shippers of Johnlock (that’s the Holmes-Watson pairing fueling endless Sherlock Holmes fan fiction) will eat this book up. Readers looking for a fresh spin on cozy fantasy romance will be enchanted, and look forward to returning to Havelock and Sebastian in future series entries.
A version of this story appeared originally on the Porter Square Review of Books. Buy “The Killing of a Chestnut Tree” from Porter Square Books.

